No problemsetter would copy problems

Revision en7, by TheScrasse, 2022-09-10 14:26:52

UPD: I was wrong :(

UPD2: I was wrong, again.

Hello everyone,
I see that many people complain about copied problems. Their claim is that authors weren't able to come up with some problems, and decided to copy them from other sources instead.

Comments of last round

Although a contest shouldn't have already used problems, please convince yourself that no problemsetter would copy problems deliberately. The presence of some problems from the Internet is accidental. So, it's not correct to accuse the authors to "copy" the problems.

FAQ:

Q. The statement is completely the same, isn't it obvious that the problem was copied?
A. No. Proof: I invented 844C - Sorting by Subsequences and 1088D - Ehab and another another xor problem, with the same statement. Usually, if you want to write the statement formally, there is only one way that's much more convenient to use that the others.

Q. Maybe you remembered the statement because you had already read it without solving the problem?
A. No. Proof: I invented 1501C - Going Home and arc130_d before the contest.

Q. How is it possible that no author / tester was able to find the "copied" problem by googling?
A. Challenge: find arc115_e on Google, using only the statement of 1591F - Non-equal Neighbours.

Tags copy, google

History

 
 
 
 
Revisions
 
 
  Rev. Lang. By When Δ Comment
en7 English TheScrasse 2022-09-10 14:26:52 32 Tiny change: 'wrong :(\n\nHello ' -> 'wrong :(\n### UPD2: I was wrong, again.\n\nHello '
en6 English TheScrasse 2022-07-24 19:45:05 26 Tiny change: 'Hello ever' -> '## UPD: I was wrong :(\n\nHello ever'
en5 English TheScrasse 2021-12-12 22:50:19 256
en4 English TheScrasse 2021-12-12 22:50:00 128 Tiny change: ' there is a way that'' -> ' there is only one way that''
en3 English TheScrasse 2021-12-12 22:48:30 29 Tiny change: 'lem:1088D].\n\nQ. Ma' -> 'lem:1088D], **with the same statement**.\n\nQ. Ma'
en2 English TheScrasse 2021-12-12 22:47:53 4 Tiny change: 'tests/arc130/tasks/arc' -> 'tests/arc115/tasks/arc'
en1 English TheScrasse 2021-12-12 22:45:16 1248 Initial revision (published)